Unraveling the Flat Earth Myth: Persuasive Techniques and Logical Fallacies

Unraveling the Flat Earth Myth

Persuasive Techniques & Logical Fallacies 11th Grade English Presentation (5 Minutes)

---

Photo by Yousef Espanioly on Unsplash

• Introduction to Flat Earth
• Key Claims by Proponents
• Scientific Counterarguments
• Rhetorical Analysis & Fallacies
• Conclusion & Takeaways

---

Photo by Aleyna Çatak on Unsplash

• Ancient belief that Earth is flat, revived in 19th century by Samuel Rowbotham
• Modern Flat Earth Society founded 1956 by Samuel Shenton
• Views Earth as flat disk surrounded by ice wall (Antarctica), often with dome firmament
• Gained traction online since 2010s via YouTube and social media

• Horizon always looks flat, no curvature visible
• Water doesn't curve; oceans should 'fall off' globe
• High-altitude flights/balloons show flat horizon
• Gravity is density/buoyancy; no spherical pull
• NASA and space agencies fake globe photos

---

Photo by Gaël Gaborel - OrbisTerrae on Unsplash

Flat Earth Claims

• Horizon always flat
• No curvature on water
• Sun/moon tiny & close

Globe Evidence

• Ships vanish hull-first (curvature)
• Eratosthenes' wells experiment (240 BC)
• Satellite photos, ISS live feeds
• Lunar eclipses show Earth's round shadow
• Foucault pendulum proves rotation

• Appeal to ignorance: 'No one can show me the curve, so Earth is flat'
• Confirmation bias: Ignoring satellite images, focusing on 'flat horizon' photos
• Conspiracy appeal: 'NASA fakes everything; globe is government control'
• Cherry-picking: Bedford Level experiment ignores refraction
• False dichotomy: 'Either believe Flat Earth or you're brainwashed sheep'

Flat Earth theory relies on emotional appeals and fallacies, not empirical evidence. Science proves spherical Earth via observation & experiment.

Takeaway: Question claims, analyze rhetoric, seek verifiable facts. Thank you! Questions?

---

Photo by Easy Lee on Unsplash